Malpractice coverage for physicians standard carriers have declined or non-renewed — after a prior claim, a board action, a gap in practice, a high-risk procedural profile, or an unconventional employment structure. When the admitted market says no, we place you through the specialty, surplus lines, and risk-retention markets that say yes.
At Homewood Insurance, we specialize in placing physicians the standard market will not touch. A single paid claim, a board complaint, a lapse in coverage, or a move into a high-risk procedural specialty can flag a physician as "hard to place" — and once an admitted carrier declines or non-renews, finding replacement coverage becomes its own problem.
The answer is rarely just paying more. It is knowing which markets write these risks — the non-admitted surplus lines carriers, risk retention groups, and high-risk pools that exist precisely for physicians the standard market has turned away. This page explains what makes a physician hard to place, what coverage costs across the risk spectrum, and how we place it.
What our customers say
Nick LeRoy
Extremely pleased with the assistance that I received.
He was timely with his responses.
Google Review
Devoted Doc
Ralph has been an excellent partner for our practice. He's responsive
and gives us the insight we need.
Google Review
Ben G. Adams
Extremely pleased with the assistance that I received.
He was timely with his responses.
Google Review
John McDonald
Responsive and detailed with necessary information to supply a
solid plan and coverage.
Google Review
Jordanna Kirschner
Ralph was very helpful in answering all my questions and concerns.
Google Review
Andrane Gordon
It was a pleasure I was expecting this was going to take weeks —
he was very efficient communicating with me and my assistant.
Google Review
Carolyn Gurski
Ralph was easy to work with, stayed in touch and communicated well.
Very happy.
Google Review
Amanda Shrewsbury
Ralph and Amy are an awesome team to work with!
10/10 recommend working with them!
If you have been declined, non-renewed, or quoted an impossible number, tell us your situation on the quick quote form — the specialty, the claim or board history, and where you practice. Homewood works with the markets that write hard-to-place physicians, and we will tell you honestly what is achievable.
Insurance for Hard-to-Place Physicians can include:
Professional liability for physicians with prior claims, board actions, or disciplinary history.
Coverage after a non-renewal, a lapse, or a gap in practice.
Placement through surplus lines carriers, risk retention groups, and high-risk pools.
Prior-acts and tail arrangements to rebuild continuous coverage.
Limits to $1M per claim / $3M aggregate, with excess and umbrella layers where required.
INDUSTRY PRICING DATA — 2026
What Hard-to-Place Physicians Pay
Current 2026 market data at $1M/$3M limits. Hard-to-place pricing carries a loading over standard rates, and it climbs with the severity of the risk — from $12,000–$25,000 for a low-risk specialty with a manageable history to $75,000–$200,000 for a severely impaired risk placed through the excess-and-surplus or risk-retention markets. The number is driven by the risk profile — claims, board history, and specialty — not by the physician's skill.
$12,000 – $25,000
Low-risk specialty, manageable history
$75,000 – $200,000
Severely impaired risk — E&S or RRG markets
4 markets
Placement routes when admitted carriers decline
The problem is access, not price
Once a standard admitted carrier declines or non-renews a physician, the instinct is to expect a bigger bill. The real obstacle is narrower: most admitted carriers simply will not quote the risk at all. Placement then depends on reaching the markets built for it — non-admitted surplus lines (E&S) carriers, risk retention groups (RRGs), professional liability trusts, and state high-risk pools — each with different appetites for claims history, board actions, and specialty. The single most damaging thing a hard-to-place physician can do is let coverage lapse: a gap compounds the problem, because the next carrier sees both the original trigger and the break. Continuous coverage, a documented prior-acts position, and a clear account of what changed after the incident are what turn a decline into a placement.
Annual premium by risk profile
Professional liability at $1M/$3M limits. These are hard-to-place ranges — they already carry a loading over standard rates for the same specialty. The top tier is placed through excess-and-surplus or risk-retention markets. Bar heights use a square-root scale so the lower tiers stay legible.
$12–25K
Low-risk specialty
$18–45K
Moderate-risk
$45–120K
High-risk surgical specialty
$75–200K
Severely impaired risk (E&S / RRG)
Where hard-to-place coverage comes from
Surplus lines (E&S, non-admitted)
most declined risks
Risk retention groups (RRGs)
physician-owned groups
Professional liability trusts
specialty pools
State high-risk pools
last resort
These are the four routes we use when the admitted market declines, roughly in order of how often they solve the problem. Bar length reflects how frequently each is the answer, not a price. Which one fits depends on your specialty, your history, and your state — matching the risk to the right market is the work.
An unconventional or multi-state employment structure
↓Improves placement
Continuous coverage with no lapse
A clear, documented account of what changed after the incident
Time elapsed since the last claim or action
A completed remediation, monitoring, or CME program
A stable retroactive date and prior-acts position
A single specialty within a defined scope
Complete, honest loss runs at application
The trajectory matters more than the event. A physician who has kept continuous coverage and can show what changed after an incident places very differently from one with the same claim and a coverage gap.
The Cost of Insurance for Hard-to-Place Physicians
Hard-to-place premiums carry a loading over the standard rate for the same specialty, and they rise with the severity of the risk and the market required to place it.
Estimated Annual Ranges ($1M / $3M Limits)
Low-risk specialties with a manageable history: $12,000 – $25,000.
Severely impaired risk, placed through excess-and-surplus or risk-retention markets: $75,000 – $200,000.
General Liability: $750 – $2,500.
For context, our standard physician cost guide shows what the same specialties pay without a hard-to-place loading — the gap between the two is what a prior claim, board action, or coverage gap actually costs.
How Hard-to-Place Pricing Works
The trigger, not the specialty, sets the starting point: a claim, a board action, or a non-renewal moves you out of the admitted market before specialty is even considered.
The market determines the price: surplus lines and risk-retention groups price the same physician differently, so matching the risk to the right market is where the saving is.
Continuous coverage lowers cost: an unbroken history, even with a claim in it, places better than a clean history with a gap.
Time heals pricing: distance from the last incident, with no repeat, steadily improves terms and can eventually return you to the admitted market.
Honesty at application is non-negotiable: an undisclosed claim discovered later voids cover when you need it most.
We place physicians the admitted market has declined — a prior claim, a board action, or a non-renewal is where we start, not where we stop.
Access to the alternative markets — surplus lines, risk retention groups, professional liability trusts, and state high-risk pools, each matched to the risk.
We fix the lapse problem — prior-acts and tail arrangements to rebuild the continuous coverage that improves every future renewal.
We build the submission — presenting your claim narrative, remediation, and time-since-incident in the way underwriters need to see it.
We plan the route back — as your history seasons, we work to move you back toward the admitted market and standard pricing.
Call 947-274-3093 or Fill Out the Form
Ralph Schiller
Ralph specializes in placing hard-to-place physicians at the best available price. You can call him or fill out the form and he will get your message directly.
