Skip to content
Search icon

Malpractice Insurance for Surgeons

Malpractice Insurance for Surgeons 

Surgeons operate at the highest levels of medical precision—where skill, timing, and judgment determine outcomes measured in lives. Every surgical procedure, whether elective or emergent, carries an inherent risk of complications, and even with flawless technique, unexpected results can lead to litigation. The financial and reputational stakes make comprehensive malpractice coverage essential for every surgical professional and practice.

Homewood works closely with surgical specialists to structure malpractice insurance that fits their practice profile, procedure mix, and exposure level. Whether you’re a general surgeon performing abdominal procedures or a subspecialist handling complex oncologic, bariatric, or spinal cases, we match you with carriers experienced in high-risk surgical lines.

This page explains the following

Get a Free Quote Now

The fastest way to find the most suitable insurance coverage for surgeons is to fill out our quick quote form, so we can give you an idea of the type of insurance coverage that best suits you.

Homewood Insurance works with a number of different carriers to ensure you have the most suitable insurance coverage at the best price.

Card image icon

Malpractice Insurance for Surgeons can include:

  • Covers elective and emergent surgical procedures in hospital or outpatient settings.
  • Protection against surgical error, post-op infection, bleeding, or anesthesia complications.
  • Includes staff coverage for surgical assistants, nurses, and anesthesiologists.
  • Optional coverage for office-based procedures and ambulatory surgical center work.
  • Defense for credentialing, supervision, and equipment liability claims.
  • Limits up to $1M per claim / $3M aggregate.

More information

Insurance for Surgeons can include:

Malpractice or liability insurance can provide essential protection against these risks:

  1. Professional Liability (Malpractice)

Professional Liability (or Medical Malpractice Insurance) is the cornerstone of a surgeon’s protection plan. It covers legal costs, settlements, and judgments arising from allegations of negligence, surgical error, or omission during the course of patient care. 
    1. Protection for elective and emergency surgical procedures across hospital and ambulatory settings.
    2. Legal defense for complications such as bleeding, infection, anesthesia issues, or retained surgical materials.
    3. Coverage for diagnostic, operative, and postoperative care errors, including delayed response to complications.
    4. Defense for credentialing, informed consent, supervision, and scope-of-practice disputes.
    5. Staff liability for nurses, surgical assistants, CRNAs, and OR teams under your direction.
    6. Optional endorsements for robotic-assisted and laparoscopic techniques.
    7. Retroactive (prior acts) and tail coverage for claims arising after policy expiration.
    8. Entity coverage available for incorporated practices, surgical centers, or group operations.
    9. Limits typically offered at $1 million per claim / $3 million aggregate, with higher limits for high-risk specialties.

  2. General Liability

General Liability coverage protects your practice from third-party claims not directly tied to surgical care—such as accidents occurring on your premises or related to business operations. 

    1. Bodily injury protection for incidents like patient or visitor falls in the waiting room or surgical suite.
    2. Property damage liability for equipment-related incidents or accidental damage to leased premises.
    3. Coverage for business operations at hospitals, outpatient centers, and office-based surgical facilities.
    4. Legal defense for claims involving business reputation or advertising injury.
    5. Protection for employees, visiting physicians, and support staff during day-to-day non-clinical activities.
    6. Standard limits up to $1 million per occurrence / $3 million aggregate, with options for umbrella coverage when required by hospitals or surgical centers.

This coverage safeguards the financial health of your practice from non-medical liability exposures.

⬆ Back to contents

The Cost of Malpractice Insurance for Surgeons:

Surgical malpractice insurance costs vary by specialty, location, procedure complexity, and experience.

Typical annual premiums (for $1M / $3M limits):

  • General Surgeons: $25,000–$45,000
  • Orthopedic Surgeons: $30,000–$60,000
  • Neurosurgeons: $50,000–$110,000
  • Plastic Surgeons: $20,000–$40,000
  • Vascular or Cardiothoracic Surgeons: $40,000–$85,000

Key pricing factors:

  • Surgical subspecialty and procedure mix (e.g., high volume of spinal or bariatric cases).
  • Claims history or prior payouts.
  • Surgical setting (hospital-employed vs. private practice).
  • Geographical Location (rates are highest in New York, Florida, Illinois, and Pennsylvania).
  • Board certification and years in practice (rates typically decline after 5+ years without claims).
  • Policy type—claims-made policies cost less initially but require tail coverage; occurrence policies offer longer protection at higher cost.

Homewood helps surgeons compare quotes from multiple carriers to balance cost with comprehensive coverage—ensuring no gaps between hospital requirements, private practice needs, or staff responsibilities.

⬆ Back to contents

why do surgeons need insurance?

Surgeons face a unique set of challenges and high stakes in their profession, making malpractice or liability insurance essential. The nature of surgical work, involving invasive procedures to diagnose, treat, or manage various health conditions, inherently carries significant risks of complications and adverse outcomes. Here are key areas where surgeons are vulnerable to being sued for malpractice:

  1. Surgical Errors: This includes errors made during surgery, such as operating on the wrong site (wrong-site surgery), leaving surgical instruments or materials inside the patient, or performing the wrong procedure. These errors can lead to severe patient harm and are among the most direct causes of malpractice suits against surgeons.

  2. Postoperative Complications: Complications arising after surgery, such as infections, bleeding, or unexpected adverse reactions, can sometimes be linked to the surgeon’s actions during or after the procedure. While not all complications are preventable, failure to adequately manage or respond to these outcomes can result in claims of negligence.

  3. Failure to Obtain Informed Consent: Surgeons must ensure that patients are fully informed about the risks, benefits, and alternatives to the proposed surgical intervention. Failure to obtain proper informed consent can lead to legal action if patients suffer adverse outcomes they were not adequately warned about.

  4. Diagnostic Errors: While primarily associated with pre-surgical care, errors in diagnosing a patient’s condition can lead to unnecessary or incorrect surgical interventions, potentially causing harm and opening the surgeon to liability.

  5. Failure to Monitor Postoperative Care: Surgeons are responsible for postoperative management or must ensure proper handoff to other care providers. Negligence in monitoring a patient’s recovery or failing to recognize postoperative complications promptly can lead to worsened outcomes and potential lawsuits.

  6. Communication Failures: Miscommunication with the surgical team, other healthcare providers, or the patient can lead to errors in the surgical procedure or postoperative care, impacting patient safety and outcomes.

  7. Anesthesia Complications: Although anesthesiologists or nurse anesthetists typically manage anesthesia, surgeons play a role in preoperative assessments and monitoring. Complications related to anesthesia, if not properly anticipated or managed, can lead to patient harm and implicate the surgical team in malpractice claims.

Malpractice or liability insurance provides financial protection against claims of negligence or malpractice, covering legal defense costs, settlements, and judgments. For surgeons, this insurance is crucial for mitigating the financial and professional risks associated with the complex and high-risk nature of surgical care.

Westwood Insurance work with a number of different carriers to source the most suitable insurance for surgeons at the best price. Contact us today.

Additional Resources

MedPro Group
Core Specialty
CNA Logo
Travelers Insurance
CFC Underwriting
Applied Underwriters
Tokyo Marine Insurance Group
crum-forster-bw
AIG Insurance
Ironshore
Strategic Comp
MagMutual
Genstar
Beazley
Empro Insurance
Great American Insurance
Skyward Specialty Insurance
Hudson Insurance Group
Huntersure Insurance
MIG Insurance
Kinsale Insurance

High-Risk Procedures and their Impact on your Premiums

While chemotherapy and standard radiation are widely covered, carriers closely review other services that carry elevated risk:

Procedure / Specialty Focus Why It’s High Risk (Key Complications) Impact on Premiums / Coverage
Spinal Surgery Involves decompression or fusion of spinal cord or nerve roots; risks include nerve injury, paralysis, infection, and disproportionate outcomes versus initial condition. Premiums 20–50% higher than orthopedic baseline; may require separate underwriting for complex cases.
Hip / Knee Joint Replacements Risks include infection, clotting, implant failure, or revision surgery; long recovery and permanent disability increase claim severity. Adds 15–30% to orthopedic rates; carriers may require higher limits for volume practices.
Obstetric Deliveries / C-Sections Potential for fetal or maternal injury, delayed intervention, or hemorrhage; subject to “nuclear verdicts.” Premiums up 30–40%; limited carrier appetite in high-litigation states.
Gynecologic Oncology Surgeries Organ perforation, bleeding, recurrence, or incomplete resection; long-term disability claims common. +25–35%; may exclude experimental or adjunctive therapies.
Bariatric Surgery Risks include leaks, malnutrition, infection, and long-term complications requiring readmission. +20–40%; carriers review surgeon volume and credentialing.
General Abdominal Surgeries Routine procedures like hernia repair or appendectomy can involve bowel injury, adhesions, or infection. Baseline rates; +15–25% if performed in high volumes or with emergent cases.

⬆ Back to contents

Other types of Insurance Surgeons may need?

 
General Liability Insurance

General Liability Insurance

General Liability covers medical expenses and attorney fees which result from bodily injuries and property damage that your facility or organization could be legally responsible for.
 
 
Business owner's policy (BOP insurance)

Business owner's policy (BOP) insurance

A Business Owner’s Policy (BOP) is a comprehensive insurance package designed for Medical Professionals with small to medium-sized businesses. It provides a blend of liability protection and property insurance.
 
 
Professional Liability Insurance

Professional Liability Insurance

Professional Liability Insurance overs any negligence or mistakes made by the individual surgeons during their practice. It differs from General Liability insurance, which covers the practice itself. 
 
 
Commercial Auto Insurance

Commercial Auto Insurance

This is relevant for surgeons who use a vehicle for practice-related tasks. This insurance covers you against auto accidents, theft, and other vehicle-related incidents.
 
 
workers compensation insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance is usually mandated by law. It protects surgeons practices and employees in case of work-related injuries or illnesses.
 
 
Cyber Liability Insurance

Cyber Liability Insurance

Covers you against financial losses associated with data breaches, cyber attacks, and other cyber incidents. Insurers will usually conduct rigorous testing of your online system to fix vulnerabilities as part of this policy.
 

Why Work With Homewood

  • Specialized expertise: We work with surgeons across general, orthopedic, vascular, plastic, and neurosurgical disciplines.
  • Access to 100+ carriers: Including admitted and specialty markets offering tiered rates for surgical risk classes.
  • Custom policy structure: Combine GL, PL, and entity coverage under one program to meet hospital credentialing requirements.
  • Competitive underwriting: We help document your surgical volume, credentialing, and peer-review processes to qualify for preferred pricing.
  • Flexible options: Tail, prior acts, and umbrella coverage available for complex surgical groups and ambulatory centers.
  • Proactive renewal management: We track litigation trends, venue shifts, and carrier appetite to keep your coverage current and cost-effective.

Call 947-274-3093 or
Fill Out the Form

Ralph Schiller

Ralph Schiller

Ralph specializes in sourcing the most suitable insurance for Surgeons at the best price. You can call him or fill out the form and he will get your message directly.