Skip to content
Search icon

Insurance for Mental Health Service Providers

Insurance for Mental Health Services 

Mental health providers deliver essential counseling, medication management, and crisis support—but the nature of this work also creates unique liability exposures. From high-acuity cases and suicide-risk management to confidentiality and teletherapy, practices and facilities need liability coverage tailored to the realities of behavioral health.

Homewood Insurance helps mental health professionals and organizations secure the right coverage to protect clients, clinicians, and reputation. This page outlines what your insurance should include, how much it typically costs, and which services can increase premiums or trigger carrier scrutiny.

  • What Insurance Includes – summary and detailed breakdown of Professional Liability and General Liability protections for mental health providers and facilities.
  • Cost of Coverage – typical premium ranges and factors influencing price based on size, scope, and services.
  • Higher-Risk Exposures – procedures, populations, and settings that elevate premiums or risk coverage denial.
  • Why Work With Homewood – how we help mental health providers navigate underwriting and secure the best coverage.

Get a Free Quote Now

The fastest way to find the most suitable insurance coverage for mental health services is to fill out our quick quote form, so we can give you an idea of the type of insurance coverage that best suits you.

Homewood Insurance works with a number of different carriers to ensure you have the most suitable insurance coverage at the best price.

Card image icon

Insurance for Mental Health Services can include:

  • Covers claims of misdiagnosis, failure to prevent harm, or breach of professional boundaries.
  • Covers claims of misdiagnosis, failure to prevent harm, or breach of professional boundaries.
  • Protection for individual and group therapy, crisis intervention, and medication management.
  • Applies to psychiatrists, psychologists, therapists, counselors, and clinical social workers.
  • Includes liability for documentation errors, treatment plan issues, and privacy violations.
  • Coverage limits up to $1,000,000 per claim / $3,000,000 aggregate; tail and retroactive coverage available.

More Information

Insurance for Mental Health Services can include:

Malpractice or liability insurance can provide essential protection against these risks:

  1. Professional Liability (Malpractice)

    1. Misdiagnosis or delayed diagnosis; ineffective/inappropriate treatment.
    2. Failure to prevent harm (suicide, self-harm, or harm to others).
    3. Breach of confidentiality (HIPAA), boundary violations, dual relationships.
    4. Failure to obtain informed consent; inadequate supervision of interns/associates.
    5. Documentation errors or omissions affecting defensibility.
    6. Applies to psychiatrists, psychologists, LCSWs, LMFTs, LPCs, and behavioral health NPs/PAs.
    7. Includes liability for teletherapy, school-based services, residential programs, and outpatient clinics.
    8. Optional coverage for substance use disorder counseling, family therapy, and case management.
    9. Tail coverage and prior acts protection available for individuals and group practices.

  2. General Liability

    1. Premises liability for bodily injury and property damage (e.g., slip-and-fall).
    2. Facility exposures across private offices, community mental health centers, correctional facilities, schools, and telehealth hubs.
    3. Negligent supervision/security, patient-on-patient incidents, and personal/advertising injury (where covered).

Homewood Insurance Group work with  different insurance carriers to find you the most suitable coverage at the best price. Get a quick quote now.

⬆ Back to contents

Cost of Coverage:

Premiums are influenced by specialty mix, litigation environment, facility size, and claims history. Carriers also evaluate risk management protocols such as credentialing, peer review, and informed consent.

Professional Liability (PL / Malpractice) – Estimated Ranges

  • Individual outpatient therapist: $500 – $2,000 annually.
  • Psychiatrists: $5,000 – $10,000+ annually.
  • Group practices/facilities (procedure/acuity dependent): $10,000+ annually.

Key pricing factors: scope of services, prescribing/medicine management, patient acuity, claims history (frequency/severity), credentialing/supervision, documentation and risk controls, venue/tort climate, limits/deductible, retro date.

General Liability (GL) – Estimated Ranges:

  • Small outpatient practice: $500 – $1,500 annually.
  • Mid-size clinic: $1,500 – $5,000 annually.
  • Mental health facilities/residential care: $5,000+ annually.

Key pricing factors: facility size and foot traffic, supervision ratios and security, incident history, 24/7 operations, and contractual requirements (e.g., additional insureds).

⬆ Back to contents

MedPro Group
Core Specialty
CNA Logo
Travelers Insurance
CFC Underwriting
Applied Underwriters
Tokyo Marine Insurance Group
crum-forster-bw
AIG Insurance
Ironshore
Strategic Comp
MagMutual
Genstar
Beazley
Empro Insurance
Great American Insurance
Skyward Specialty Insurance
Hudson Insurance Group
Huntersure Insurance
MIG Insurance
Kinsale Insurance

High-Risk Procedures and their Impact on your Premiums

Insurers rarely refuse standard outpatient counseling, but they can decline or heavily modify terms when operations fall outside licensure/scope, show repeated severe losses, or fail regulatory compliance. More commonly, certain procedures, populations, and settings drive surcharges or higher retentions due to elevated frequency/severity (e.g., med errors, suicide exposure, inpatient incidents).

Procedure Category Examples Why Higher Risk? Insurance Impact
Psychotropic Medication Management Antidepressants, antipsychotics, stimulants; polypharmacy Adverse reactions, overdose, failure to monitor side effects/compliance 30–50% PL surcharge; stricter underwriting and follow-up requirements
Pediatric / Adolescent Prescribing Off-label use, complex behavioral cases, foster-care populations Vulnerable population, limited long-term data, higher litigation rates 50–100% PL surcharge; limited carrier appetite without strict protocols
Interventional / Neuromodulation ECT, TMS; ketamine/esketamine therapy for TRD Anesthesia exposure, dissociation/BP spikes, seizure risk, inefficacy claims 20–200% PL increase depending on modality; often E&S placement for ECT/ketamine
Inpatient / Residential / Crisis Programs 24/7 facilities, crisis stabilization units, group homes High acuity, suicide/self-harm, elopement, assaults Premiums can double or triple; higher retentions and security warranties
Suicide Risk Management Caseloads Clients with active ideation or recent attempts Failure-to-warn/intervene exposure; documentation scrutiny 25–75% PL uplift if a significant portion of caseload is high-risk
Group / Family Therapy Multi-person sessions in outpatient or facility settings Confidentiality breaches, conflicts, physical altercations 20–40% surcharge to PL and GL depending on population
Teletherapy for High-Risk Cases Acute clients treated remotely across locations Tech failures, limited in-person intervention, cross-venue/licensure issues 10–30% PL uplift; exclusions if non-compliant with licensure/HIPAA
Vulnerable Populations SUD, developmental disability, elderly clients Higher negligence/abuse allegations; complex comorbidities 15–50% surcharges; SAM sublimits or separate SAM policy may apply
Unlicensed / Beyond Scope Activities Non-physician prescribing, experimental therapy w/o approvals Regulatory violations; non-defensible standard of care Declination by standard markets; E&S only with strict warranties
Frequent / Severe Prior Claims Multiple malpractice suits; suicide or misconduct losses Signals systemic risk; poor controls Declination common; E&S with high rates/retentions and audits

⬆ Back to contents

Other types of Insurance Mental Health Services may need

 
General Liability Insurance

General Liability Insurance

General Liability covers medical expenses and attorney fees which result from bodily injuries and property damage that your facility or organization could be legally responsible for.
 
 
Professional Liability Insurance

Professional Liability Insurance

Also known as malpractice insurance, this  protects facilities against claims related to malpractice, negligence, or injury resulting from resident care. Staff members like medical professionals and counselors will typically be covered by professional liability insurance.
 
 
sexual-molestation

Sexual Abuse and Molestation Insurance

Provides coverage for your organization against claims arising from alleged sexual misconduct or molestation by an employee or other representative of your organization. Essential for the social services industry.
 
 
Commercial Property Insurance

Commercial Property Insurance

This protects your facility against damage or loss to your buildings, equipment, and other property, which can happen as the result of various risks such as fire, theft, or vandalism.
 
 
workers compensation insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance is usually mandated by law. It protects mental health services and employees in case of work-related injuries or illnesses.
 
 
Cyber Liability Insurance

Cyber Liability Insurance

Covers you against financial losses associated with data breaches, cyber attacks, and other cyber incidents. Insurers will usually conduct rigorous testing of your online system to fix vulnerabilities as part of this policy.
 

Why Work With Homewood

  • Deep specialization in mental and behavioral health across solo, group, and facility settings.
  • Access to nearly 100 carriers, including psychiatry/counseling specialists and surplus lines markets.
  • Guidance on consent-to-settle terms, Hammer clause variants, retro/tail strategy, and entity structuring.
  • Proven placement for higher-acuity services (ECT, ketamine, residential) with realistic retentions and controls.
  • Practical risk-management playbooks focused on documentation, supervision, licensure, and telehealth compliance.

Call: 608-395-7545 or
Fill Out the Form

Chris-for-web

Chris Worley

Chris specializes in sourcing the most suitable insurance for Mental Health Services at the best price. You can call him or fill out the form and he will get your message directly.