Skip to content
Search icon

Insurance for Youth Service Providers

Insurance for Youth Service Providers 

At Homewood Insurance, we help youth organizations secure the liability coverage they need to protect children, staff, and volunteers. This page gives you a clear breakdown of:

Get a Free Quote Now

The fastest way to compare options is our quick quote form. We’ll review carriers and provide a tailored proposal that protects your staff, your volunteers, and the youth you serve.

Card image icon

Insurance for Youth Service Providers can include:

  • Professional Liability for supervision failures, abuse allegations, or reporting issues.
  • General Liability for third-party injury or property damage involving youth, families, or visitors.
  • Coverage for after-school programs, youth shelters, counseling centers, and juvenile support.
  • Applies to counselors, youth workers, therapists, volunteers, and administrators.
  • Standard limits: $1M per claim / $3M aggregate, with tail and retroactive options..

More information

Insurance for Youth Service Providers can include:

This insurance can provide essential protection against these risks:

  1. Professional Liability (Malpractice)

    1. Allegations of failure to supervise, neglect, or abuse.
    2. Defense for failure to report, improper documentation, or poor intervention.
    3. Coverage for counseling, crisis response, mentoring, and reunification programs.
    4. Applies to social workers, therapists, behavioral aides, case managers, and volunteers.
    5. Optional endorsements for respite, wraparound, transitional living, and juvenile justice programs.

  2. General Liability

    1. Premises liability for playground accidents, falls, or altercations.
    2. Property damage caused by youth, visitors, or staff during activities.
    3. Personal & advertising injury for defamation or privacy violations (non-clinical).
    4. Suitable for nonprofits, community centers, drop-in programs, and foster care support.
    5. Coverage limits up to $1M/$3M, with endorsements for SAM coverage and state/grant compliance.

Homewood Insurance Group work with  different insurance carriers to find you the most suitable coverage at the best price.

Get a quick quote now.

⬆ Back to contents

Cost of Coverage:

Premiums vary by program size, services offered, staff training, claims history, and state litigation environment. Carriers also focus heavily on abuse prevention protocols, background checks, and reporting compliance.

Professional Liability (PL / Malpractice) – Estimated Ranges

  • Small nonprofits (mentoring, after-school only): $1,500–$3,000 annually.
  • Mid-sized agencies (counseling, shelters, crisis response): $4,000–$8,000 annually.
  • Larger multi-site organizations (wraparound, transitional, or juvenile justice): $10,000–$20,000+ annually.

PL premiums increase significantly when programs provide mental health, substance abuse, or crisis intervention services, or if they have prior claims for abuse/neglect.

General Liability (GL) – Estimated Ranges:

  • Small programs (community center, drop-in): $800–$2,000 annually
  • Mid-sized facilities with recreation or transportation: $2,500–$6,000 annually
  • Large organizations with multiple sites and high foot traffic: $7,000–$12,000+ annually.

GL rates are driven by premises safety (playgrounds, gyms, sports), transportation exposures, and incident history. Strong facility safety measures and training often reduce costs.

⬆ Back to contents

Higher-Risk Activities and Insurance Impact

Carriers evaluate youth programs carefully. Coverage can be denied if safeguards are absent, or premiums increased 20–50%+ for higher-risk services.

Procedure/Activity Risk Description Insurance Impact
High-Impact Recreational or Sports Activities Contact sports, stunts, or adventure programs increase injury and assault risks Premiums rise 20–40%; some carriers exclude certain sports unless safety protocols are in place
Transportation of Youth Accidents during trips; driver training and vehicle safety often lacking Adds GL/auto exposure; premiums increase unless strict policies and maintenance records are shown
Behavior Management / Restraint Procedures Physical restraints or corporal punishment increase claims for negligence or abuse Surcharges or exclusions unless documented, non-physical alternatives are used
Mental Health, Drug/Alcohol, or Crisis Interventions Counseling and crisis services expand PL risk for failure to warn or improper referrals Premiums rise 20–50%; underwriters prefer licensed staff and clear protocols
Inadequate Incident Reporting Failure to report abuse or notify carriers of incidents within required timelines Claims history worsens; higher renewal premiums and stricter conditions imposed

⬆ Back to contents

MedPro Group
Core Specialty
CNA Logo
Travelers Insurance
CFC Underwriting
Applied Underwriters
Tokyo Marine Insurance Group
crum-forster-bw
AIG Insurance
Ironshore
Strategic Comp
MagMutual
Genstar
Beazley
Empro Insurance
Great American Insurance
Skyward Specialty Insurance
Hudson Insurance Group
Huntersure Insurance
MIG Insurance
Kinsale Insurance

Other types of Insurance Youth Service Providers may need

 
General Liability Insurance

General Liability Insurance

General Liability covers medical expenses and attorney fees which result from bodily injuries and property damage that your facility or organization could be legally responsible for.
 
 
Professional Liability Insurance

Professional Liability Insurance

Also known as malpractice insurance, this  protects facilities against claims related to malpractice, negligence, or injury resulting from resident care. Staff members like medical professionals and counselors will typically be covered by professional liability insurance.
 
 
sexual-molestation

Sexual Abuse and Molestation Insurance

Provides coverage for your host home against claims arising from alleged sexual misconduct or molestation by an employee or other representative of your organization. Essential for the social services industry.
 
 
Commercial Property Insurance

Commercial Property Insurance

This protects your facility against damage or loss to your buildings, equipment, and other property, which can happen as the result of various risks such as fire, theft, or vandalism.
 
 
workers compensation insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance

Workers Compensation Insurance is usually mandated by law, to protect youth service providers and their employees in case of work-related injuries or illnesses.
 
 
Cyber Liability Insurance

Cyber Liability Insurance

Covers you against financial losses associated with data breaches, cyber attacks, and other cyber incidents. Insurers will usually conduct rigorous testing of your online system to fix vulnerabilities as part of this policy.
 

Why Work With Homewood

We guide youth organizations through the underwriting process by:

  • Reviewing abuse prevention protocols and staff training
  • Ensuring coverage for counseling, mentoring, and recreational activities.
  • Negotiating SAM coverage, deductibles, and endorsements to meet state and grant requirements.

Call: 608-395-7545 or
Fill Out the Form

Chris-for-web

Chris Worley

Chris specializes in sourcing the most suitable insurance for Youth Service Providers at the best price. You can call him or fill out the form and he will get your message directly.